Abortion is legal in Maine! Learn More

Navigating Labels in the Gay Community

by a UMaine Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies student and Mabel Wadsworth Center intern

As someone who identifies as gay, one thing I’ve come to notice within the gay community is that labels are everywhere. There are so many different ways to describe yourself as a gay guy; in fact, you’re expected to, at least from my own experience. A lot of the time, labels tend to be forced upon people in one way or another–if you present more feminine, you’re probably going to be told that you’re a bottom, whether that’s actually true or not. Depending on your body type, you will likely be assigned a “tribe” label whether you want it or not. This is unfortunately a prominent thing within gay communities, and even those who aren’t gay may take it upon themselves to assign gay men and those perceived as men a label. But why are we so insistent on putting people into boxes? And why can’t we let them decide to label themselves if they want to? It’s important to shine some light on this “label policing,” specifically among gay men, and explain why it’s better to allow people to identify with labels on their own instead of forcing them upon them, as well as the negative feelings having a label forced on you might bring.

One of the biggest issues I’ve come to notice regarding labels is that, due to stereotypes and cliches, people like to make a big deal out of gay men’s sexual positions. If you’re very masculine, muscular, and/or taller, it is likely going to be assumed that you are a top, or the person who is performing penetration during penetrative sex. If you happen to be more feminine presenting/acting, slimmer or less muscular, and/or on the shorter side, odds are people will assume you are a bottom, the person receiving the penetration. In a lot of cases, it’s not a quiet assumption–these labels are often forced purely based on stereotypes, regardless of accuracy. As someone who presents in a more androgynous/feminine way, I have been told by people that I am a bottom, that I look or act like a bottom, and that I give off “bottom energy,” and this has persisted even after stating that that isn’t true. In a lot of cases it may be a joke, but it is both frustrating and intrusive to have this label forced on me. The “bottom” stereotype is based mostly on assumed feminine presentation and behavior, suggesting that if you’re feminine, you’re “weak” and can’t be in control, which of course goes back to the rampant sexism and misogyny that is rooted within our society. This also has always felt rather odd to me from a privacy perspective–people love to look at a gay couple and guess who’s the bottom and who’s the top (which really boils down to who is perceived as the “man” in the relationship and who is seen as the “woman”), but it shouldn’t matter to anyone else what goes on within two consenting people’s sexual relationship. It is simply nobody else’s business. Everything about this makes me and so many other gay men uncomfortable, and it is an issue that deserves far more attention.

The other main instance of this forced labeling that I have seen and experienced has to do with body types. Within the gay community, there are “tribes” (the use of the word “tribe” like this is its own issue to break down) which separate people by body type: “twink” for skinny, non-muscular people; “otter” for those who are more muscular and hairy but still slim; “bear” for larger, hairier men, and so on and so forth. While these labels aren’t necessarily intended to cause harm, they can lead to exclusion, especially when forced upon others, and tend to make people think that it is acceptable to be rude and/or straight up offensive to those with body types that they don’t find attractive (“no fats, no fems”). And in a community that should be focused on sticking together and supporting each other, it’s always felt strange that we’ve felt a need to separate ourselves into groups based on body types when, in reality, there should be more of a focus on support and making sure everyone feels completely welcome, no matter their appearance. It is worth noting that in some cases, these labels can be empowering for those who choose to self-identify with them. Specifically, many people who use the bear label have formed a community that fights fatphobia and emphasizes that all bodies are welcome within the gay community. These labels are only harmful if they are forced or used to make people comply with certain standards – if people choose to use them, they can be a way to oppose exclusion and make people feel more welcome. 

While I can’t speak for others, one particular thing that I have noticed through my own experiences is that if your body type falls into the “twink” category, that label will be forced on you, and so will the expectations that come with it. The biggest one that I have noticed is shaving. Many gay men seem to heavily fetishize those with the “twink” body type, which is already an issue, but they also very commonly expect that people who have that body type will always be completely clean-shaven. In a lot of cases, this is such a prominent expectation that those who do not comply are put into a spot where they are alienated and made to feel unattractive by others. Not only does this create a negative overall environment where some people feel the need to alter their appearance just because they have a specific body type (which they have no control over!), but it makes those who don’t comply feel like they are repulsive or doing something wrong. Not only is this frustrating for those who deal with it, but it also has odd roots and implications. One piece is the idolization of appearing youthful. We, as mammals, naturally grow hair on our bodies as we mature, and making others feel as though removing it is the peak of attractivity implies a preference for immature or even underage people. Something about it is very strange. This expectation is also rooted in misogyny and control over women, as women are also constantly made to feel as though they need to shave to be a “proper” woman and be seen as attractive, which is a norm that was pushed on them (and still is!) by patriarchy. This translates over to the feminine appeal that people with the twink body type seem to have to other gay men, and to keep this “proper” feminine look, they need to be clean shaven at all times or else they are not attractive.

There is so much more that could be discussed regarding forceful labeling within the gay community as well as the rest of the LGBTQ+ community, as it is a constantly recurring issue that people still have to put up with to this day. This is a serious issue that needs to be addressed to a greater extent, as it often puts people down and makes them feel like they need to be something that may not feel right to them. So much of this forced labeling is rooted in misogyny, and demonstrates the need for the integration of more feminist ideals within our society. When used voluntarily, labels can be amazing for one’s own autonomy — having the ability to put a label on oneself can make it easier to feel included in a group with other similar people, and can allow for a better understanding of oneself as well, as labels can describe parts of people that they may not have understood or had a name for before. Labels are important and helpful to many people both within and outside of the LGBTQ+ community, but it is crucial that we fight against label policing to keep labels positive for those who need them.